It verifies 100% what I wrote in Sweethearts.
The nurse I interviewed and quoted in the book spoke to someone else some weeks later. The problem with that second interview was this: the people who taped it and others who listened to it continued to deny the truth of it, as it didn’t fit their agenda. Over the decades, that has proven to be a disservice, not only to Jeanette MacDonald but to Nelson Eddy as well.
“I didn’t know she was dying. I’ll never get over it,” Nelson told the press in the immediate shock and confusion after learning of Jeanette’s death.
By 1973, I had already heard deeply upsetting accounts of Jeanette’s final two weeks—first from friends of Jeanette; ie, the “Jeanette side,” as well as her sister Blossom.
Then there was the “Nelson side.” His friends confirmed the depth of his distress. Jeanette’s bedroom telephone had been removed because she was considered “too weak” to have it. Yet daily phone calls had been the lifeline of Jeanette and Nelson’s relationship for decades, particularly because their professional lives so often kept them apart. Nelson traveled extensively for concert tours and, later, his nightclub engagements.
He was upset that his calls to Jeanette were being redirected to Gene Raymond’s number. It would appear he understood that a home nurse was caring for Jeanette, so presumably he didn’t have to worry; but he did not know that, the very day after his last visit with her, Gene dismissed that nurse.
In those early years, I asked Blossom difficult questions. One was whether she knew when Jeanette and Nelson had ceased having a physical relationship. Jeanette was suffering from congestive heart failure, a condition that at the time often brought a slow decline and a life expectancy that, at best, was 5 years. And that’s basically what it was for Jeanette. It might have been longer had she been strong enough to undergo the planned surgery with Dr. Michael DeBakey. He had just performed a similar procedure on Edward VIII, the Duke of Windsor, extending his life almost another eight years.
Blossom answered that question. Later, with a friend present, I asked whether she knew when Jeanette had last spoken with Nelson by phone. We knew what Nelson told the press after he had regained some composure: that their last call was “about a week” before her death. He then offered a polished PR reason for that phone call—that he and his wife, Ann, had discussed getting together with Jeanette and Gene for dinner.
That account was, of course, complete nonsense. To the bitter end, Nelson felt he had to keep up the pretense that he and Jeanette were no more than casual friends. But according to what Blossom revealed, Jeanette was then almost too weak to walk from her bedroom to the living room and had to cling to the walls for support. Nelson had seen, during his final visit, that she was essentially bedridden. Years later, when I interviewed Susan Nelson—the nurse involved—she confirmed that Jeanette’s telephone had been removed from her room and that Jeanette needed assistance at home even to walk to the bathroom.
During that final call, Jeanette told Nelson that she was fine and that she simply wanted to hear his voice. That was typical Jeanette: minimizing her own suffering because she did not want to worry him. She refused to let Blossom call him back, to tell him the truth. There are many documented instances over the years in which he became hysterical—at times to the point of collapse—when Jeanette was seriously ill. When she was hospitalized in 1963, Nelson was in Australia but abruptly cancelled his tour, pleading throat problems, and rushed back to the States.
Now Katie Gardner has uncovered additional documentation that again corroborates this account while revealing still more about the cruel neglect Jeanette endured in her final days. It is difficult to comprehend, but it is true.
Katie’s blog post is essential reading. Its revelations are heartbreaking. The link is here.